A perpetual debate has existed – white composite fillings against silver amalgam fillings. Both options serve the same fundamental purpose: to restore teeth damaged by either cavities or breaks. However, they differ in composition, aesthetics, durability, and more. Let's dive into the intricacies of these two types of fillings to shed light on this enduring dispute.
Composition
White Composite Fillings: Composite fillings are made of a mixture of acrylic resin and powdered glass. This material can be shaded to match the natural color of teeth, making it a popular choice for visible areas. At Fallon Dental Arts we have many shades to choose from. We also often utilize a composite that will change color to match the surrounding tooth structure more ideally.
Silver Amalgam Fillings: Silver amalgam fillings are composed of a blend of metals, including silver, mercury, tin, zinc, and copper. While they are cost-effective and durable, their metallic appearance can be off-putting for those concerned about aesthetics. However, there are still indications, even in this modern world, for amalgam use.
Aesthetics
The most noticeable distinction between white composite and silver amalgam fillings is their appearance. Composite fillings blend seamlessly with the natural tooth color, making them virtually undetectable. On the other hand, silver amalgam fillings are conspicuous due to their metallic sheen, often causing self-consciousness in individuals, especially when smiling or speaking.
Durability
In terms of durability, silver amalgam fillings have long been favored for their robustness. They are highly resistant to wear and tear, making them a reliable choice for the back teeth that endure significant chewing force. Conversely, white composite fillings, while durable, may be perceived to not last as long. This perception may be related to the technical aspects of proper bonding (topic for another post) and that because they are white we see cavities quicker than with an amalgam.
Health Considerations
White Composite Fillings: Composite fillings are mercury-free, which appeals to those concerned about potential health risks associated with amalgam fillings. They require less removal of the natural tooth structure for placement, promoting tooth preservation.
Silver Amalgam Fillings: Although the safety of amalgam fillings has been debated, reputable dental associations have deemed them safe for use. However, the mercury content raises concerns for some individuals, especially pregnant women and those with allergies to certain metals. At Fallon Dental Arts we make sure that when we are dealing with amalgam we are intentional in our handling and disposal of it.
Verdict
The choice between white composite and silver amalgam fillings ultimately depends on several factors, including personal preferences, budget, and location of the filling. While composite fillings excel in aesthetics, silver amalgam fillings offer more durability in certain situations. Dr.Fallon will make sure you are given the most up to date information to make an informed decision that aligns with your specific needs and priorities.
The white vs. silver filling debate is nuanced, with both options presenting distinct advantages and considerations. This is compounded by the fact that each clinical situation is unique. But rest assured that when the time comes to make this decision our team will have an honest and open conversation with you and allow you to make the best decision for yourself.
Remember, when it comes to your dental health, informed decisions pave the way for a brighter, healthier smile.
Комментарии